Pizza restaurants

Pizza Americana

4.3 232 reviews 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM 1917 E Railroad St, Heidelberg, PA 15106, United States

Discover this place

Pizza Americana in Heidelberg, PA, has garnered an enthusiastic following thanks to its consistently remarkable offerings and warm service. Customers rave about the Spicy Chicken pizza, praised for its bold flavors, as well as the meatball calzone, which stands out for its exceptional doughy texture and fresh ingredients. Reviews highlight the aesthetic appeal and impeccable presentation of dishes, underscoring the pride taken in their preparation. The Antipasta Salad and Apple Cranberry Salad are also favorites, balancing the richness of pizza with refreshing flavors. The restaurant’s diverse menu caters to various tastes, featuring a range of calzones, salads, and the beloved New York-style pizza. Many patrons appreciate the reasonable prices, making Pizza Americana a go-to spot for both casual meals and special occasions. The friendly staff consistently enhances the dining experience, ensuring that every visit is enjoyable. Additionally, the efficient service during busy times shows their commitment to customer satisfaction. Whether you opt for the recommended Italian calzone with a twist of white sauce or a classic pizza, Pizza Americana promises flavorful dishes that leave a lasting impression. Overall, it’s a local gem that excels in delivering quality and taste, making it highly recommended for anyone in the area.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pizza Americana before visiting.

Reviews for Pizza Americana

4.3

232 reviews

100%

17%

15%

Review highlights

Based on 232 reviews

Pizza Americana in Heidelberg, PA, consistently receives positive feedback for its quality and flavor. Reviewers frequently highlight the fresh, well-prepared dough and the careful balance of sauce and cheese, contributing to a satisfying eating experience. The restaurant's varied menu appeals to diverse tastes, with particular praise for specialty items like calzones and New York-style pizzas. Customers appreciate the appealing presentation and the evident pride in craftsmanship. Service is noted as friendly and attentive, enhancing the overall dining or takeaway experience. Reasonable pricing and reliable delivery further establish Pizza Americana as a favored local option for both casual meals and special occasions.

Brandi

Jun 03, 2025

I found out about this place thru the app Slice. And ever since day one it’s always been fire. Better than the other places I’ve went around here (Carnegie) to be honest. Now I appreciate food. So presentation of a meal means a lot to me as well. And 9 times out of 10 it looked beautiful and 10/10 tastes great. I feel like the ovenist takes pride in his work. You can taste/see it!I have not bought pizza from any other place since I’ve found Pizza Americana

Kevin Nelson

May 20, 2025

Pizza Americana is consistently great. We've ordered from here several times and we've never been a bad experience. The Spicy Chicken pizza is fantastic!

Nicholas Basile

Apr 28, 2025

We got a meatball calzone, NY style pizza, and hand tossed pizza. Of the 3 items we had, my favorite was the meatball calzone. Of the 2 pizzas we had, we preferred the NY style pizza. However, the hand tossed pizza did have its appeal. The calzone and hand tossed pizza bad a very doughy profile that was very nice -- it tasted very fresh with a high gluten protein content; very nice. The NY style pizza was much different, but had a very desirable sauce/cheese/crust matrix. The service was excellent, the employees were awesome and friendly, and the order was ready in very little time late at night, where most other places were closed. I highly recommend this place.

Jasmine Ullrich

Apr 28, 2025

Pizza Americana has never failed to make every visit enjoyable. The employees are very nice and provide excellent service. The menu offers a wide variety of options. The prices are very reasonable, making this pizza shop a great choice for a regular meal or even for special occasions. I highly recommend this pizza shop to anyone who is local to Scott/Carnegie/Heidelberg or surrounding areas! I personally recommend getting the Italian calzone, but if it’s your thing.. replace the red sauce with white sauce. Tastes amazing and it’s our go to every single time!!

Kaely Montgomery

Apr 09, 2025

We’ve been here a couple times and each time we’ve had a pleasant experience. Friendly staff and pizza has been great. The perfect ratio of sauce to cheese every time.

Robert Leech

Mar 29, 2025

Back home in the 'Burgh last week and had to stop and get the most underrated pizza in the area. The dough and sauce are just perfect. The people that work there are always the friendliest.

Chrissy McFadden

Feb 20, 2025

I love everything about Pizza Americana. The price is great, delivery is fast, and all the food is fantastic. I have never had something I didn't like from there. I love all the salads, the Sicilian pizza is bomb, the New York style pizza is the best New York style pizza I've had this side of the Appalachian Mountains. Also, the dry rub wings are delicious and I love that I can order all flats or wings. The desert is even good!! Seriously, you can't go wrong with this place.

Daniel “Dan” Gerson

Feb 08, 2025

We discovered Pizza Americana through the slice app. Their hand tossed pizza is very good, but recently, we tried their New York style thin crust and friends, it is some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life! It is unforgettably delicious and crave-worthy! After decades of the eternal search for reliably amazing pizza, my search has come to an end. It's Pizza Americana for us, and the NY style thin crust for me! While delivery is super convenient, I'll want to stop in at some point to personally thank them and heap praise in their direction.